Disturbing the Universe

David L Clements, science and science fiction

Drive by posting: 2 Cultures, Networking and Talking to the Press

Leave a comment

You know how it is. Ideas for possibly lengthy posts come along, but the pile of exam papers to be marked doesn’t get smaller by itself, you have interesting research to do, and you want to push ahead with revisions of the Work In Progress. So the ideas falter and never get expanded or baked to the length they might deserve.

A few of these have cropped up recently and, in the absence of energy to expand them, I’ll just add them here in short form for your delectation.

  • Last week, during a discussion on Twitter, Damien G Walter, who writes about SF for the Guardian among other things, made a comment along the lines of ‘as someone trained in both the arts and sciences, I feel sorry for those trained in only one’. I agree with that, but I’d go one further. In most cases I feel more sorry for the ‘arts’ people not trained in the sciences, than for those like myself forced to drop arts subjects at 16 by the English educational system. The reason I say this is because you can, to some extent at least, learn the missing bits of the arts in your own time. Possible evidence I’ve had some short stories published, something your average english student probably doesn’t even manage. However, while teaching yourself a science on your own time is certainly possible, it’s a lot harder than developing your arts education on your own. Some knowledge of science, and experience of the scientific way of thinking, I think adds great depth to your appreciation of the world around you.
  • One thing that surprised me about the various appreciations of Iain Bank’s life and work over the last weeks and months was the number of people saying they had met their husbands or wives through his writing. I didn’t really understand this at the time, but today, thanks to a long post by a friend on a different social media site, I now know how at least some of that worked, through people meeting other Banks fans via the Culture mailing list. This got me to thinking how social media in all its forms is changing the way we interact. In past decades, meeting new people wasn’t that easy. Too often one would be constrained by geography, by links within existing social groups, or by other circumstances. Meeting people genuinely new to you would be difficult. Now, all that could be just a click away through a list dedicated to some common interest, like the writings of a favourite author. Is this something fundamentally different? If I knew more about network theory I might be trying to work this out.
  • Finally, a rather worrying report on BBC news today about how scientists working for government agencies in the UK feel, or are told, that they shouldn’t be talking to the media. This is the kind of gagging that has brought strong criticism of the Canadian government, which brought in strict controls on what and how its scientists can and can’t say to the media. The British way is rather different from the Canadian approach. Rather than an explicit gag, we have the dim and nebulous threat of the Official Secrets Act to hang over people. This can lead to insidious self censorship when you don’t know what you can or can’t say to the press. The safe thing to do, of course, is just to say nothing. I’m glad university scientists in the UK are rather freer to talk to the media, at least at the moment. But what I’ve heard about signatures on formal ‘non-disclosure agreements’ being required of scientists working on some future ESA missions is rather worrying, These would seem to go beyond things like the Planck (lack of) communication policy to a whole new level of interference with academic freedom. These are not developments that should be encouraged.

So there it is, a drive by posting.


Author: davecl

Astronomy, science, science fiction

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s