Disturbing the Universe

David L Clements, science and science fiction

The Beginning of The End


Yesterday marked the end of the UK’s membership in the Gemini Observatory. The Union Flag was lowered during a brief ceremony, and it is now presumably being packed up for return to STFC in Swindon.

You can see more pictures from the ceremony here.

This event is the first stage in the withdrawal of the UK from the Northern Hemisphere. Our departure from Gemini means that the UK no longer has access to 8m class optical/near-IR telescopes in the north. Over the next several years, if STFC’s planned funding cuts to astronomical observing facilities go through, the UK will also lose UKIRT (see previous postings) and the JCMT on Hawaii, and with it the highly successful WFCAM IR survey camera and the unique and yet-to-be fully exploited SCUBA2 submm camera on JCMT. In two years time the northern hemisphere rump of UK astronomy will be a small partnership in the ING telescopes in La Palma, and how long this involvement will continue is far from clear.

This decision to ‘not compete’ in the north is a result of funding erosion over a number of years. Telescopes are being closed to protect the grants line and our subscription to ESO and the future southern hemisphere large projects EELT and SKA. Given the funding environment this isn’t an unreasonable decision, but the decisions to cut astronomy funding that have led to this conclusion are something that I, and all other UK astronomers, would argue with – both at STFC level and more broadly in BIS and the rest of government.

The departure from Gemini is the start of this round of closures. If the funding cuts continue, and we don’t see some restoration of the astronomy budget in the next few years, quite where they will end is unclear.


Author: davecl

Astronomy, science, science fiction

2 thoughts on “The Beginning of The End

  1. I count (but may have mis-counted) a grand total of five UK PIs in ALMA cycle 1: http://almascience.eso.org/news/alma-early-science-cycle-1-outcome-of-the-proposal-review-process

    I hope Science Board heed the warnings from AAP.

  2. Bit more complex than that – at least one of the ‘NA’ PIs is now moving to the UK, for example, but your point is well made.

    And STFC’s press release on the Gemini withdrawal today:


    comes over as barefaced propaganda. It’s just embarrassing to see them claiming that the withdrawal is to ‘enable investment in other ground-based telescopes’ and ‘securing a strong UK involvement in the future of ground based astronomy’ when the fundamental problem is the cuts to astronomy within STFC. I guess the same release will go out when UKIRT and JCMT close, ignoring the fact that their loss will damage our place in ground based astronomy. Without SCUBA2 to feed ALMA projects, for example, we’ll end up as also-rans in submm astronomy, a field that the UK pretty much invented.

    I know the person who wrote the press release is only doing their job, but anybody with an ounce of knowledge about what’s going on will see right through it.

    I also hope that Science Board heeds the warnings, but while they’re prepared to give extra money to DIAMOND, ISIS and particle physics at the expense of astrophysics, I can’t feel optimistic.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s